Have a quick gander at these comments:
"... the sound issues are a result of the 'loudness war' – an ongoing
industry effort to make recordings as loud as possible"
Sean Michaels, The Gaurdian
"... mixes were already brick-walled before they arrived"
Ted Jensen according to Rolling Stone
Yes, many in-the-know fans and critics thought the production on Metallica's "Death Magnetic" plain sucked. Way too squashed.
A bad mix can and will be slaughtered by audio pros and audiophiles. "Brickwalled!" "No dynamic range!" "The kids today!" #loudnesswars
They are 100% correct. The DAW waveform looks like a smooth sausage. Dynameter says "no". I mean, just look at it!...
So, that all said, given and accepted. Still...
Not too shabby a performance for such a poor mix & master, hey?
Point is, bad mix or not, it found an audience.
... attention to detail and nuance is a much-needed ability for any music
producer worth their salt. Impeccable taste and high standards are of
course also wanted in an artist or music producer.
Attention to detail is however also often the "reason" productions take too long and in some cases don't even get released. If you're like me you can spend hours sweating the tiniest of details of a mix. Tweak upon tweak upon tweak. It's not just dynamic range. It's stereo width, depth, balance, tone, timbre. On and on. Tweak, tweak, tweak.
This is all good unless it prevents you from shipping new tracks often.
1. Some people call your released mix horrible and others like it.
2. Your mix never sees the light of day and lives in obscurity with your other non-perfect mixes on your back-up drive.
This is not to say you should release crappy mixes!
This is to say that often "good enough" is fine.
Does it make you feel something? It may be good enough.
Knowing when to stop is an ability you pick up by finishing new music often.
Fact #1: You may never like any of your mixes 100% and that's OK.
Fact #2: You're not the final arbiter when it comes to your musical output. That's other people's job. You're in no position to judge well. There's a bubble and you're in it. Leave it to the punters, mate.
Do your best.
Then, get Zen with it.
Say it's done so that it's done.
Let it go.
Win some, lose some. Fine.
At least you're in the game!
quest for the perfect mix, or Perfect Mix Syndrome as I call it, can
provide a smokescreen to hide our fears, doubts and insecurities. It may just be our old friend, Resistance. We
cannot get bad comments on tracks that aren't released. Thing is; we
don't get much else either.
We must, if we suspect fear or insecurity are at the root of our p(erfectionism)(rocrastination), face our demons and release new music more often.
The more we make it a habit to finish new music the easier it becomes to let go and move on to the next project. Quantity leads to quality.
Quantity also leads to the ability to know when a mix is done.
P.S. This isn't a pardon for over-squashed mixes. More dynamic range is usually a good thing. Check your dynamic range.
P.P.S. Good enough still has to be above a certain quality level, of course. You'd be surprised what you can get away with though.
P.P.P.S. Please share this post if you like it. Thank you!
Learn to understand equalisers and frequencies to supercharge your mixing skills and get results, fast...
New producer? Learn everything you need to produce your first professional track right now...
Would you like to discover the simplest and easiest way to learn music theory as a music producer?